#OCCULTOBER: Revisiting The Shadows Over Somerset Giveaway Occult Detective Results

The Shadows Over Somerset contest was interesting. The rules were simple: email me your favorite Occult Detective and then I would draw a winner at random, sending them a signed copy of the book and writing an essay about their selection.

Here are the Occult Detectives and the number of votes they tallied:

4 Thomas Carnacki
4 Fox Mulder
3 John Constantine
3 Dean Winchester
2 Harry Dresden
2 Carl Kolchak
2 Dana Scully
2 Levi Stoltzfus
1 Greg Newkirk
1 Greg & Dana Newkirk
1 Ed Warren
1 Ed & Lorraine Warren
1 Edward Carnby
1 Dr. Spektor
1 Duke De Richleau 
1 Alexandra Trese
1 Shido
1 Hellboy
1 Landon Connors
1 Bob Freeman

I find it interesting that five of the 34 votes went to real people: myself, the Newkirks, and the Warrens. Greg Newkirk and Ed Warren each got one vote, while they and their respective partners received one vote.

The continued popularity of Thomas Carnacki among occult detective fans never ceases to amaze me.

I was surprised to see Fox Mulder tie for first place with four votes and Dana Scully received two votes. While I knew the X-Files had a huge cultural impact, I didn’t count on them still being so popular.

There were two Occult Detectives I didn’t know that received votes — Shido, a vampire character from an anime series called Nightwalker — The Midnight Detective and Edward Carnby, an investigator and researcher who is the main protagonist in Alone in the Dark.

How did Scooby and the Gang not even draw a single vote?

Overall, I was thrilled with the results of the contest and was happy to see so many entrants. As for the subject of the Hunter’s Moon Occult Detective essay, well, I am less than thrilled about that one. I’ll have to cook something up special for that…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: